Andy, Will It Work? Makeup lines promise glamour at drug-store - Action News 5 - Memphis, Tennessee

Andy, Will It Work? Makeup lines promise glamour at drug-store prices

Posted: Updated:
Andy Wise and cosmetic professionals are applying these products to help you make up your mind over your makeup. Andy Wise and cosmetic professionals are applying these products to help you make up your mind over your makeup.
Will Revlon Colorstay, L'Oréal True Match, and Covergirl Queen Collection work? Will Revlon Colorstay, L'Oréal True Match, and Covergirl Queen Collection work?
  • News on WMCTV.comNewsMore>>

  • 2 escape early morning house fire

    2 escape early morning house fire

    Monday, April 21 2014 10:29 AM EDT2014-04-21 14:29:04 GMT
    (WMC-TV) – A Memphis homeowner and his roommate woke up to fire early Monday morning at a home on Ingles Avenue near Kansas Street. The fire department received multiple calls about fire around 2:30 a.m. WMCMore >>
    A Memphis homeowner and his roommate woke up to fire early Monday morning at a home on Ingles Avenue near Kansas Street.More >>
  • Police cancel City Watch for 13-year-old

    Police cancel City Watch for 13-year-old

    Monday, April 21 2014 10:17 AM EDT2014-04-21 14:17:47 GMT
    The Memphis Police Department has issued a City Watch for 13-year-old Tara Duncan.More >>
    The Memphis Police Department has canceled a City Watch for 13-year-old Tara Duncan. MPD issued the cancellation at 9 a.m. on Monday after she was located.More >>
  • Bang for Your Buck: Spend your tax refund wisely

    Bang for Your Buck: Spend your tax refund wisely

    Monday, April 21 2014 10:02 AM EDT2014-04-21 14:02:59 GMT
    (WMC-TV) – Tax season has come and gone for most of us, which means if you are owed a refund, you either have it by now or are expecting it soon. In this segment of Bang for Your Buck WMC Action NewsMore >>
    Tax season has come and gone for most of us, which means if you are owed a refund, you either have it by now or are expecting it soon.More >>

(WMC-TV) ANDY, WILL IT WORK?  Makeup Marketed to Women of Color = ????

Women of color are desperately seeking the right color.

Estheticians will tell you:  makeup for African American women is about matching three things: skin color, skin type and skin tone.

The problem is some women of color like Whitney Joy of Collierville, TN, have to blend two skin tones, light and dark. She spends $50 a shot on department store brands, only to be "dragged through the mud."

"I look ‘muddy' all over," she said. "It looks like I've played in the mud! So it's really frustrating."

So she got really excited when she started seeing commercials like the ones with Halle Berry and Queen Latifah. They tout value-priced, brand-name makeup lines, marketed to women of color. They project department store glamour at drug store prices.

We collected Joy's color matches and shopped the foundation, eye shadow and lipstick of THREE of the lines:

* Revlon's Colorstay, $28.47/set

* Loreal's True Match, $27.97/set

* CoverGirl's Queen Collection, $18.81/set

She took turns applying each line, wiping her face clean between each application.

Her conclusion:  "I didn't come to a conclusion," she said in frustration. "I look like a ghost!"

"Women of color, we have what we call ‘facial masking,'" said Autumn Seymour, an esthetician in training at the Tennessee Academy of Cosmetology, 7041 Stage Rd, "which is we have two colors – one light, one dark -- and sometimes, we have to get two colors to put on your face to make it look good."

Alisa Kuykendall, the school's head esthetician, said the value-priced make-up lines marketed for women of color could be excellent choices if consumers first get a professional analysis of their skin colors, tones and types.

"I would recommend go to a professional, have your make-up done," Kuykendall said. "Have them go over colors and what to use, and then use that as your guideline for (shopping) other makeup."

Copyright 2013 WMC-TV. All rights reserved.

  • Are you a loyal user of one of these makeup lines?

  • Thank you for participating in our poll. Here are the results so far:

    Yes. I use Revlon Colorstay.
    16%
    25 votes
    Yes. I use L'Oréal True Match.
    14%
    20 votes
    Yes. I use Covergirl Queen Collection.
    22%
    32 votes
    No. None of these lines have ever worked for me.
    48%
    70 votes
Powered by WorldNow